Why is my water softener making noise? Often because it's regenerating, which is what it's meant to do. Culligan puts it plainly: "Some sound during regeneration is normal as water flows and valves change positions." The sound itself tells you little. When it happens, how long it lasts and whether it stops tell you more.
What a normal regeneration sounds like
A conventional softener cleans its resin by running water through it in stages and down the drain. Between stages the control valve shifts, so you hear a short whirr or click, then water again.
The Whirlpool WHES40/44 manual describes two of those stages. In the brine stage there's "a slow flow of water to the drain." In backwash there's "a fast flow of water from the drain hose." A trickle, then a rush, with pauses between. That's normal.
Cycle length depends on your model and settings. Culligan's advice: "Check your owner's guide for the expected cycle length."
Why you usually hear it at night
Single-tank electric softeners are normally set to start in the small hours. Whirlpool's recharge time comes up as 2:00 AM, and the Pentair whole-house softener manual says "2:00 AM is good for most households." The house gets unsoftened water while it runs, so Whirlpool says: "Avoid using hot water while the softener is regenerating."
Twin-tank and water-powered softeners can run any time
The Kinetico Signature Series owner's manual explains that its systems work on demand, without timers or electronics, so the softener "regenerates whenever necessary, at any time of day." One tank supplies soft water while the other regenerates. On a unit like that, daytime regeneration is normal.
Hearing it at the wrong time of day
A single-tank unit that suddenly regenerates mid-afternoon may have lost its clock setting in a power cut.
- Whirlpool says that after an outage, "regenerations may occur at the wrong time of day until you reset the clock."
- The Fleck SXT owner's manual says the time of day flashes after a power failure. A regeneration missed during the outage is queued for the next programmed time.
- Pentair's manual says that if the power is off long enough, "the clock will restart at 8 AM and will need to be reset."
If the time on the display is flashing or wrong, set it using your manual's steps. If the timing is right but it seems to run too often or too rarely, see how often a water softener should regenerate.
Water running to drain that won't stop
Take this one seriously. Culligan says that if the softener runs past the expected cycle length, "repeatedly restarts regeneration or continues sending water to the drain," get it serviced.
Troubleshooting tables list several possible causes:
- Fleck 5600SXT (service manual), "Drain flows continuously": the valve isn't programming or positioning correctly, foreign material in the control, or an internal control leak.
- Clack WS1 (service manual), "Water running to drain": a power outage during regeneration (the control finishes the remaining time once power is back), a damaged seal/stack assembly, or a failed piston.
That first Clack cause isn't a fault at all: a softener that lost power mid-cycle can sound stuck when it's only finishing. So the sound alone doesn't prove the valve has failed. If the flow never stops, finding out why means stepping the valve through its positions, which is water softener repair work.
Regenerating more often than it used to
Normal-sounding regenerations that come more often may just mean more water use. Kinetico's manual says leaky plumbing, dripping taps and running toilets "can contribute to more frequent regenerations." Check the toilets first. A leak you can't track down is a job for leak detection.
Grinding, squeaking or hissing
EcoWater says: "Unusual sounds can be an indicator your softening system isn't working correctly. Grinding, squeaking and hissing are especially common."
You can't tell which part is at fault from outside the cabinet. Clack's manual is clear about who goes inside: "No user serviceable parts are on the PC board, the motor, or the Power supply," and "Service and maintenance should be performed by qualified personnel only."
Your part:
- Write down any error code. The Fleck SXT owner's manual sends several of its codes to "your local water treatment professional."
- If it's leaking, put the softener in bypass and call. Kinetico's manual describes its bypass as the way to take the system offline for service.
Banging pipes: usually water hammer
Banging pipes usually aren't the softener. The Watts LF15 water hammer arrestor sheet blames "shocks of high speed water flowing in the piping system when a fixture is suddenly closed," and names dishwashers, clothes washers and fast-closing shutoff valves.
The installation can add to it: Pentair's manual says that if a check valve between the softener and the water heater causes "water hammer", install a water hammer suppressor.
The clue is timing. A thump the moment a dishwasher or washing machine stops filling points at the pipes, not the softener, and that falls under plumbing repairs. If the noise seems to come from the water heater, see why your water heater is making noise.
Checks to run before calling
- When does it happen? At the programmed time, a new time, or when an appliance shuts off?
- Is the clock right? Flashing or wrong points to a power interruption.
- Any error code? Write it down exactly.
- Is water still going to drain past the cycle length in your manual?
- What's the salt like? Culligan warns salt can harden into a bridge that interferes with brine. Tank full of water? See why your water softener has water in it.
- Is the bypass in the service position?
- Is the drain hose kinked or run up high? Whirlpool lists a restricted drain ("bends, kinks, elevated too high") as a cause of back-pressure that can stop brine draw.
- Is the water hard at the tap? Then something's wrong, whatever the noise.
- What's the model number? Whirlpool's is on a rating decal, typically on the rim below the salt lid hinges.
What not to do
- Don't open the control head or touch the motor, board or wiring.
- Don't oil anything. Clack: "Do not lubricate the motor or the gears."
- Don't break a salt bridge by pounding on the tank or with anything sharp. Whirlpool warns you can damage or puncture it.
- Don't ignore water that keeps running to drain.
When to call
Call if water keeps running to drain past the cycle length, grinding or squealing starts, an error code keeps coming back, or it's leaking. Phone 587-834-3668 with the make and model, when the noise happens and what the display shows. We price the repair before any work starts, and we dispatch from both Calgary and Airdrie. Call and we'll tell you honestly when we can get there. See water softener repair, or in Airdrie.
If the unit is old, or undersized and cycling constantly, a repair may not be worth the money; how long water softeners last covers that call. For a replacement, see water softener installation in Calgary or water softeners in Airdrie.
