Plumbing5 min read

Why Does My Sump Pump Keep Running?

Why does my sump pump keep running? Usually heavy groundwater, a stuck float, pumped water draining back, or a pump and pit that don't suit the inflow.

Why does my sump pump keep running? Usually it's one of four things: more groundwater is reaching the pit than usual, the float is stuck or out of adjustment, water the pump already moved is finding its way back in, or the pump and pit don't suit the amount of water coming in. First rule: if water is coming in, let the pump run.

First, check whether it's keeping up

If the pump is running and the level in the pit is dropping, or holding steady, it's doing its job. It's the only thing between that water and your basement floor. Don't unplug it or switch it off to give it a rest.

If water is already on the floor, the City of Calgary says to "please stay out of your basement," and: "If you can smell gas or if the water is above the electrical outlets, call 911."

Heavy groundwater: the pump may just be busy

The City compares saturated ground to a sponge. Once the soil is full, the water table rises and more water reaches the weeping tile and the pit. A long spring rain can do it, and so can a fast melt. The City's storm drains page notes that chinook weather "can melt the snow quickly turning inches of snow into puddles in a matter of hours."

Pentair's troubleshooting FAQ says a pump that keeps going "either means you have a lot of water coming in or the float switch is stuck in the ON position." If the pump is pushing water out but the level won't drop and the pit isn't overflowing, Pentair reads that as more water coming in than it can move out.

The City's climate-ready drainage guidance says: "If it cycles frequently (e.g., daily or more frequently), you may be at high risk of flooding from pump failure." It recommends a separate backup pump that takes over if the primary fails, says "All sump pumps should have a backup power supply installed," and suggests a moisture alarm in the sump that sounds when water reaches a critical level or the primary pump fails to engage. One caution: "Do not use potable-water powered backup pumps."

Water coming up through a floor drain rather than collecting in the pit is a sewer backup, a different problem with a different fix: a backwater valve.

A float that's stuck or out of adjustment

The float switch tells the pump when to start and stop. If the float can't drop, the pump never gets the signal to stop. Zoeller Canada says debris in the pit can jam it in the on position, and warns: "Even if it looks fine, a faulty float can keep the unit running continuously." Pentair's troubleshooting FAQ also lists "Float switch is out of adjustment" among the reasons a pump runs continuously.

Float adjustment varies by pump, and your model's manual is the authority on it. To be plain about our side: FlameTech doesn't repair sump pumps. When a float or switch has failed, we replace the pump.

Pumped water coming back into the pit

A failed or missing check valve

When the pump shuts off, the water standing in the discharge pipe wants to fall back into the pit. The City says to "make sure a check valve is installed on the discharge pipe to prevent recycling of pumped water." Pentair's sump pump FAQ says the valve "prevents the pump from having to re-pump the water."

Without a working check valve, the pump empties the pit, stops, and the pipe drains straight back down, starting the next cycle. A valve fitted backwards is no help either: Pentair says its arrow should point "up toward discharge, not at pump."

Discharge that lands too close to the house

Water dumped beside the foundation can soak back through the backfill to the weeping tile and into the pit. The City: "Discharged water should clear the backfill zone of your foundation. If not, you may be recycling pumped water." Its storm drains page asks that the pump discharge "two metres from building foundations."

Citing the Community Standards Bylaw, the City also says: "Do not allow water to drain directly onto neighbouring properties, lanes, sidewalks, boulevards, streets, into a foundation drain or weeping tile." Downspouts feed the same ground; our guide to why a basement floods every time it rains covers them and grading.

Other drains emptying into the pit

Pentair: "It is NOT recommended to drain laundry or water softeners into a sump basin." If one does, the pump is moving water that never came from the ground.

Pump and pit sizing

Pentair: "Over sizing or under sizing can reduce the life of the pump from short cycling or continuous operation." A pump too small for the inflow can end up running constantly and still lose ground. A pump that empties a small pit in seconds goes the other way, short cycling on and off. Zoeller's run time article: "It's best to avoid short cycle times, which can place undue pressure on the pump."

Pentair says a larger basin lets the pump "run less frequently and longer," and that sump pumps "are designed to run intermittently, not continuously." Zoeller suggests a larger basin diameter if run time is too short, and links short cycling to the pump's on/off operating range. The horsepower needed depends on how much water comes in and how far it has to be lifted.

There's no one right horsepower or cycle count to quote here. Pump and pit get matched on site to the water your house actually takes on.

Safe things to check yourself

  • Watch one cycle from a dry spot. Does the level drop? Does the pump stop? Does water rush straight back in once it does?
  • Go outside while it runs. Is water coming out of the discharge, and where does it land?
  • Test it when the pit is quiet. The City suggests "pouring water into the sump pit and seeing whether or not the pump starts automatically."
  • Look for debris only when it's safe: a dry floor, a pump that isn't holding back incoming water, and power disconnected the way your manual describes. Pentair: "Be sure to disconnect the power to the pump before servicing it."
  • Check how it's plugged in. Pentair: "We strongly recommend that you do NOT use an extension cord."

Stop there. Outlets, wiring and cutting the basement slab are trade work.

When the answer is a new pump

A new pump is the answer when the old one can't keep up, the float or switch has failed, or the pump and pit don't suit each other. The City's guideline: "Replace your pump every 10 years, or sooner."

FlameTech installs and replaces sump pumps and pits. When only the pump has to go, our September 2026 price for a ProFlo 1/2 HP unit is about $504. If the pit itself has to go, figure on around $2,000 for the new pit and pump together. Calgary and Airdrie pay the same.

Call 587-834-3668. Quotes are free, and we price the job before any work starts. We install and replace sump pumps rather than repair them: sump pump installation in Calgary, or in Airdrie. We dispatch from both Calgary and Airdrie. Call and we'll tell you honestly when we can get there.

Keep reading

Related articles

When you're ready

Book a Red Seal plumber in Calgary.

Free estimates and upfront pricing, from local technicians who treat your home like their own.

Free estimate · No service charge for quotes · BBB Accredited